Frequently Asked Questions:

What in the world is a shoofly pie?

Shoofly Pie is a molasses and brown sugar based pie that is considered traditional in Pennsylvania Dutch Country and is also popular in the South. There are generally two versions of the shoofly pie - a wet bottomed and a dry bottomed version. Both feature two layers - a cakey/crumbly part and a gooey, molasses-y part. As their names suggest, the wet bottom version has more goo and less cake, and the dry bottom version has more cake and a thinner layer of molasses on the bottom crust. Our version is the dry bottomed version. Come on in and give it a try! We recommend it served slightly warmed with some freshly whipped cream or vanilla ice cream. Yummy.

I love pie and just want to talk about it OR I have a pie suggestion for you to make! Would you like me to share?

Yes! We love pie – all sorts of pie – and always welcome suggestions! We create a Pie of the Month every month and are always experimenting with new flavors/combinations. If the pie is a hit, it could become part of our main menu. Please submit pie suggestions to kimmy@shooflypiecompany.com or post to our facebook wall: www.facebook.com/ShooflyPieCompany If you just want share your thoughts on pie, please email Kimmy at kimmy@shooflypiecompany.com. She’d love to hear from you.

How can I place an order for a pie?

Give us a call or send us an email! For most pies, we ask for a minimum of 48 hrs (2 business days) advance notice, but we will always do our best to fulfill your pie-desires! Also, you can always reserve pies for pickup later in the day (except certain holidays) based on what is on hand at the time – just give us a call! Please note that we require prepayment for all orders.

Please note: there are some products that require up to 7 business days advance notice depending on exact product/order quantities and ingredients on hand.
Please see our Special Orders section for more information on this.

For larger orders (10 pies or more) we appreciate 1-week notice, but again, call us if you are in a pie-emergency and we will do our best to accommodate you.


Please note that for Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays, we feature limited menus and set order-by deadlines. We also make a limited amount of extra pie for day-of purchase on a first-come-first-served basis. Please call us for details or with questions.

Do you deliver?

We are happy to announce that we are now offering delivery in the Seattle, WA area. A delivery fee will be charged based on order size & delivery address (minimum $30.00 in the immediate Seattle area). Please keep in mind that we need advance notice to arrange delivery. Please contact Kimmy at kimmy@shooflypiecompany.com if you REALLY need that pie!

Do you ship pies?

We do offer shipping on certain pies and our online store is coming soon! Until then, please email Kimmy at kimmy@shooflypiecompany.com for inquiries. Please note that we currently ship overnight or 2 day via Fed Ex and while we guarantee that the pie will leave our hands in perfect condition, we can’t always predict what happens in transit. If your pie arrives in less than perfect condition, please contact us. In certain situations, we can offer a refund on the price of the pie, but not the shipping cost unless we receive a refund from our shipping partner.

Do you sell gift certificates?

You bet we do! You can purchase a gift certificate in any amount you like, and even have it in store waiting for that lucky pie lover, or put it in the mail if you can’t pick it up yourself. Give us a call today and we’ll be happy to help you.

Our gift certificates will also be available via our online store very soon!

Do you sell your tshirts, mugs and other merchandise?

Yes! Our online store is in the works, but until then, you can call or email us and we will be glad to help you.

Do you do weddings and/or large orders?

YES! We work with you to ensure you have the perfect, unique dessert for your guests on your wedding day, bridal shower or engagement party. Please call or email to make an appointment with a baker for a complimentary tasting and to discuss your plans for your special day!Delivery options are now available.

We require a 50% deposit at time of order with the remaining balance due at time of pickup.

Do you offer wholesale?

YES! We absolutely love to work with other businesses with the same ideals as ours to hopefully grow together. Please email Kimmy directly at kimmy@shooflypiecompany.com to discuss possibilities!

Speaking of…where can I find your pies, if I can’t make it out to your store?

We are proud of our wholesale relationships! This list will be updated periodically - here are some of our partners and locations where you can find Shoofly Pies!

ZOKA Coffee Roasters & Tea – our quiches and fruit pies are available at the following locations:

ZOKA Greenlake:
2200 N 56th Street
Seattle, WA 98103


ZOKA University (Behind U Village):
2901 NE Blakeley Street
Seattle, WA 98105


ZOKA Kirkland:
129 Central Way
Kirkland, WA 98033


SPUD.com Seattle (Sustainable Produce Urban Delivery) – we offer an ever growing menu for home delivery with spud.com, including pot pies, galettes, fruit pies, and key lime pie. Check out your delivery possibilities at: www.spud.com

Old School Frozen Custard – you can find yummy frozen custard made with our pie fillings, as well as our crazy good (even if we do say so ourselves) quiches at their Capitol Hill location:

1316 E Pike Street
Seattle, WA 98122

Can you customize your pies?

YES! Our pies normally have our star designs on the tops, but we can customize with dates, names, flowers, etc. instead. Pricing depends on the intricacy and length of the design and starts at $5. Please call for details.

Can you bake a pie in a customer’s pie pan from home?

We can usually accommodate a request to bake a pie in a customer’s pan, HOWEVER, we will charge more based on the extra amount of filling and/or dough required to do so. Please call ahead to discuss your options.

How should I store my pies?

Please be aware that we do not use any preservatives, dyes or coloring in our pies. They therefore should be consumed as soon as possible. Fruit pie is best stored at room temperature and in a cool dry place. Refrigeration is recommended if you will not be consuming the pie within 1-2 days, OR if the atmosphere is hot or humid (e.g. in the summer). Always keep cream pies, lemon meringue and key lime pie as well as all quiches and savory pies refrigerated until serving.

How should I heat up my pies?

Microwaving is possible, but will likely cause the crust to become soggy. Therefore, we do not recommend this method for heating.

The best way to warm pie is to heat the oven at 375-400 degrees for:

Pot Pies – 18-20 min (mini 5"), 40-50 min (large 9")

Quiches & Mac n' Cheese Pie – 13-15 min (slice), 30-45 min (whole)

Whole Fruit Pies – 15-20 min

Onion Galette, Slices, Mini Fruit Pie – 4-6 min

I am interested in joining the Shoofly Family. How can I apply?

The best way to apply for a position is to send a cover letter and resume to Kimmy at kimmy@shooflypiecompany.com. You can also drop off your information at the store during business hours. If we have any positions open and are interested in interviewing with you, we will contact you!

I would like to request a donation from Shoofly. How can I do so?

We are constantly inundated with requests for donations. While we'd love to be able to donate to all causes, we unfortunately have to pick and choose based on several factors. We gladly accept requests for donation at our store (please be prepared to drop off your information at the counter, we WILL review them) or via email to shooflypiecompany@gmail.com. Please be assured that if we are interested in donating to your cause we WILL get back to you by the deadline. We try to get back to everyone even if we are not able to donate but again, we receive so many requests that sometimes time does not allow us to do so. Thanks for your understanding.

I am an awesome artist or I know one and would love to hang my (their) work at Shoofly and participate in a monthly Art Walk.

We love local art and artists! We participate in Art Walk on the 2nd Thursday of each month from 6 to 9 pm. The artist then keeps their art up until the next Art Walk date. If you are interested in hanging at our shop, please contact Kimmy at kimmy@shooflypiecompany.com.

Please note that artists must be available to participate in the actual Art Walk event and be on site that evening.



twitterfacebook